Senators John Fetterman and Dave McCormick: Bipartisanship, Money in DC, Datacenters, Graham Platner
Guests: John Fetterman, Dave McCormick
In-depth read · Key ideas, reasoning, and examples, organized by topic.
§01Two Pennsylvania senators pitch cooperation across party lines
The excerpt opens with a news-style clip. It notes that Pennsylvania is "one of the most important states in this presidential race" and that both of its senators, Democrat John Fetterman and Republican Dave McCormick, voted for a bill to avoid a government shutdown. Voices in the clip say they agree that "shutting our government down is wrong for our commonwealth and for our nation," and describe their votes as "country over party."
we have lots of disagreements, but we trust each other, we like one another, and we look for ways to work together.
After the host invites each guest to give opening remarks, one speaker calls the other a good friend, says politics is more polarized, and says, "I refuse to engage in the kinds of extremism." Another speaker makes a broader claim: the present may be "the most consequential moment in all of our lifetimes," and possibly "in humankind." That speaker links the claim to artificial intelligence and its effects on life sciences, defense, and energy. The argument is that fast change creates anxiety, the anxiety feeds polarization, and so cooperation matters more now than ever. The speaker lists shared work on energy policy, the fentanyl crisis, antisemitism, and drone technology.
A speaker adds that "Pennsylvania keeps you honest" and says the two are "the only two people in our respective cycles that flip seats." The speaker attributes this to rejecting "the extreme kinds of views." The same speaker names AI as a point of friction with "the direction that the Democratic Party seems to be moving in." The speaker calls a moratorium on data centers "a China first kinds of policy" and says AI should be described as "an incredible new opportunity," not "a scourge." A Western Pennsylvania symposium is credited with bringing together AI and energy, which the speaker sees as two things the state "brings to the table."
§02Pennsylvania as a microcosm and the working-families coalition
The moderator asks whether Pennsylvania predicts the country: if the state can find common ground on hard issues, perhaps the nation can too. The moderator also asks what daily Senate work looks like, since "a lot of the time it just seems like nothing is happening."
One speaker says both senators grew up in rural Pennsylvania. The speaker says "John went into public service," while the speaker went to West Point and the military. The speaker describes the state as "19 electoral votes" and "a microcosm of the country": two large, mostly Democratic urban centers, Philadelphia and Pittsburgh, and rural areas that are "mostly Republican." To win, the speaker argues, a candidate has to build a coalition across both.
The concrete claim is about union voters. The speaker, who calls Bob Casey "my opponent," says national unions endorsed Kamala Harris and Casey, yet "two thirds of the rank and file, the electricians, the pipe fitters, the steam fitters" voted for the speaker, and similar voters backed the other senator. The speaker describes the coalition as including "a very significant Latino turnout" and "the highest African American turnout in 2024 in the last thirty years." The speaker calls the coalition "up for grabs" and predicts that whoever wins it "will dictate the future to a large degree in 2028 and beyond." The excerpt does not give sources for these turnout and voting figures.
§03A challenge on approval, debt and inflation, and a defense of the Iran policy
An interviewer pushes back hard. The interviewer says the Senate is "at an all time low in terms of approval rating," the president has the lowest approval in history, the debt is out of control, and inflation is "soaring." The interviewer cites "$40,000,000,000,000 in debt" and says the system is not working "for anybody but the people in this room, which is to say the top 10% of our society." The direct question is how to restore balance between the branches of government.
Keep reading as a member.
You've read the free preview. Become a member to read the rest, with side-by-side reading and downloads where available.